All the folk I'd ask would have first to come under the category you outlined. That's why I quoted you.
It just qualifies them at the minimum level. I don't mind a pilot or a surgeon being humorless. In fact, that might be an advantage. For an art critic, some sense of modesty and humor is likely to promote more useful feedback. It also removes shallow, dogmatic and rule-based reflex reactions that most often, serve no purpose other than the ego of the reviewer.
Asher
Bookmarks