I'd recommend the big island. There are certainly lots of options for touristy and not-so-touristy stays. In addition, I think the big island offers a huge amount of photographic potential to a large format photographer. Also, if you stay on the big island, there is a wide variety of locations from Hilo (which is not very touristy) to Kona. And then there are places on Hawaii that are not on the coast. I'm sure its true of any of the islands, but you could surely choose from condos, to private homes, to bed and breakfast to mega hotels.
The one thing I see as a downside to Hawaii is that the food is expensive, and yet generally not very good. There were exceptions, but you kinda had to look around for them. Well, the flight was expensive too. I think my flight to Kona cost more than my flight to Europe and was nearly as much as my flights to Singapore.
As for photography, the big island has lots to offer. I spent two weeks there, but could easily find interesting things to shoot for a month.
Bookmarks