It would be interesting to know what makes a lens a biogon derivative, or even a biogon, because even the 1951 biogon is quite different from the 1934 original.
...but if the SAs and the Nikon SW 9 f/8 are not biogon derivatives then many people are wrong.
I guess... "The basic design principle is that you have a group with negative power at each end of the lens, surrounding one group with positive power on each side of the aperture. However you slice and dice or cement these groups is immaterial to the basic concept." (A.C.)
All I know is outcomes. Later Biogons in my typical applications work so very well in managing distortion and fall-off while SA lenses strive to be more and fail. I enjoy living within the later Biogon limits.
Bookmarks