Is TRIX320 98% better than Ilford HP5 Plus ??

[Pere Casals]

We often tell ourselves stories, sometimes we even believe them. And then, once that bridge has been crossed,
we tend to believe the 'evidence' that supports us and dismiss all else. We like being 'right'.

All this blathering, on and on, pages and pages of it, filled with suppositions, logical fallacies,
specious statements presented as 'facts', ad nauseam; what's the point of all this effort?
To suggest that a film has a spectral response?! Alert the press! Design your own emulsion
and see what you get. TMX has a fairly linear response, as much or more than most films.
Millions of images have used it; it's a fine film, one of the best *ever* made,
and I will miss it when it is gone.

But what do you care?

It's not about the 'truth' here, it's about being 'right'. You're tilting at windmills.

I answer you in PM, as I was finished in this off topic.

[ben_hutcherson]

Funny, but unexposed 35mm TMX and TMY look the same as pretty much all other B&W emulsions and also give the same colors when washing.

If the pink dye were so integral to the spectral response of the film, would they not also be present in 35mm?

[Pere Casals]

Funny, but unexposed 35mm TMX and TMY look the same as pretty much all other B&W emulsions and also give the same colors when washing.

If the pink dye were so integral to the spectral response of the film, would they not also be present in 35mm?

I answer you in PM, as I was finished in this off topic.