I'm still trying to figure out what you mean by "one drop more/less iodine..." The only thing I've every heard of iodine being used for is to rush the seasoning period for a new batch of collodion. Are you trying to compare more or less iodized, amber to red, collodion, and equate that to any change in plate tones?
Garrett
flickr galleries
Yep thats my understanding to, you're basically trying to shoot for the contrast of month old collodion, now using B&S Workhorse the directions state 3-4 drop per 100 ml and I add 2 to my 65ml but that day I was adding a drop to every plate to see the effects if any. So I was taking out an 8x10s worth of collodion and adding a drop of iodine just to see the effects
I just threw these up against the wall and snapped a picture, one has more iodine in less collodion and these were the fourth/fifth plates of a 65ml mix so by the fifth pour it had 4 extra drops in the last plate than the original 65ml mix, I see a difference in these two which was 1 drop difference, exact same exposure, exact same spot 15 minutes apart, the crappy iPhone shot with all the reflections and such isn't a great determination of accuracy but the extra drop definitely appeared to add iodine colored tones and contrast as I look at them side by side
Also interesting is I was wearing a rust colored shirt and you can clearly see my reflection and it appears darker purple on the additional drop picture which is the girl. I have the pictures squared up and flat against the wall, the reflection is my 27" iMac on this forum replying
Ok I wasn't, exactly perfect by one drop when originally describing the process the first time. The first plate was the pair of them/full sun, 2 drops Iodine in original 65 ml....this plate is the second one over and silver, pretty darn accurate, next shot was obviously the other pair at the end which I purposely changed to ask this couple if they like that tone better because I can create this color in a pour if they like that look, it had an additional drop of iodine, the solo one of the guy I also adjusted for them to see I can also produce this color if they prefer it to the bright silver, it now has 3 extra drops in 3 plates less collodion, and finally the girl had four drops in less which you see in the post above
The development time has a lot more to do with tone than how iodized the collodion is. What you are seeing is just a fluke.
Garrett
flickr galleries
Be sure to track the day's UV light amount, haze or cloud cover, age of collodion, recipe/salt types used, acidity of silver bath, age of developer, type of developer, and length it stays on. Among other factors that effect tone.
But adjusting drops of iodine? Never heard of it, (other than kick-starting the iodizing process if you don't want to wait for the collodion to ripen). Collodion ripeness affects sensitivity and contrast. This is a process that was done by thousands of photographers in every town in America for generations. It's all been investigated and written up before, for over a hundred years.
Garrett
flickr galleries
Still life 1 di Filippo Natali, su Flickr
18x24cm tintype
Tachihara 8x10 - Derogy Petzval 230mm F/4
New Guy Collodion - Ferrous sulphate positive developer with sugar
Filippo
Nice still life!
Garrett
flickr galleries
Bookmarks