Since it was such a wild idea in the nudes thread that a group of photographers provide free, open, public critique of each others' work, I decided to start a new picture thread with that specifically in mind.

This should be a place where we can be 100% open and honest in picking each others' work apart in order to improve in all respects. If you hate a piece, that's fine, but think about why you hate it. What about it doesn't work for you? The same goes for loving a piece. "Great work!" is not a critique and neither is "that sucks!"

This should be a given, but let us please keep everything here respectful and constructive. Remember that critique is not personal.