Thanks to everyone for your input.
Peter (York), ColorNeg/ColorPerfect (CNCP) is the method I'm starting to use. However, for best results, it's best to feed it a purely linear file, with no color Look Up Table (LUT) applied and a gamma of 1.0.
Although CNCP can deal with files which have different gamma, I have a feeling that even when scanning negs as positives - with black and white points set to 0-255 and maximum dmax - the data in the file isn't a true representation of everything that's in the neg. It's not possible to bypass the Screen software to get the CCD data from the scanner. (that's the data that the scanner processes when it displays the "Setup" progress bar). Because of this, the LUT applied by CNCP doesn't produce the best tonality. And the GUI for that software is too convoluted for me.
This secondary method gives good results, but it's not perfect:
-scan negs as positives (scan wide so there is no clipping in low and high ends)
-in photoshop, sample the orange mask
-create a solid color layer of that sampled color
-set its transfer mode to difference (this will basically remove the orange from the image and give you a very low contrast inverterted image)
-add Levels adjustment layer
-leave the RGB adjustment alone, but tweak R G and B levels so that the rightmost triangle is as close as possible to the part of the left edge of the histogram. (you need to do this for R G and B separately)
-at this point, the low contrast image looks much better but needs a bit more work
-add a curves adjustment layer and shape the RGB curve (the main one, not each the one for each channel) so that it looks like an S (pull in the low end of the curve and push the high end
-there should be more contrast in the image now
-if there is still a color cast, add another curve adjustment layer and tweak individual R G and B or use a Selective color adjustment layer and tweak it's Neutral component
What I found the most frustrating with the Color Genius Software is that it's impossible to tweak SD and HD when scanning negs. If only I could do that, scanning negs as positives would be pointless. Ironically, Screen allows their drum scanning software to set SD and HD whether negs or slides are being scanned... Go figure.
Can someone confirm that it is NOT possible to tweak SD and HD points with Color Genius version 2 or EX?
Thanks
MD
Bookmarks