Opinions of 4x5 Developing Reels

[Fungus]

I'm just getting back into 4x5 after twenty years. I sold all my gear long ago and am starting from scratch.

I think the best option for me is a reel and tank system to develop 4x5 BW in small batches (I average 6-8 sheets per outing). The two reels I'm looking at are the MOD54 (for the Paterson tank system) and the Jobo 2509n reel in a 2500 series tank.

My question is which one of these is easiest to load in the dark?

(While I'd prefer a better option, like a Jobo 3010, that's out of my price range at the moment after buying a camera, lenses, etc. Perhaps I can consider it in a few months.)

[ethics_gradient]

I used the Mod reels when I started LF - I only had issues a handful of times (probably my fault being overly rough when agitating) but have read mixed results from others.

I bought a Stearman Press when I got back into 4x5 a year or two ago which only does 4 sheets at a time (so may not appeal to you) but find it easy to load and pretty foolproof. The smaller volume of chemistry required is also nice.

[darr]

I dropped using the Jobo 2509n years ago as it was difficult even with the load assist tool.

I have been using the MOD54 for many years, and it is not difficult, but there is a learning curve; make sure you load your film with the notch in the top LEFT position, or your film will not process correctly.
Another option when using a Paterson Tank is a B's 4x5 Developing Reel. I just received one and have not put it through its paces yet, but I think it might be easier to load than the MOD54.
Both of these reels will develop 6-4x5 films in one tank.

There are other options, but I stopped looking after the MOD54 met my needs.
I travel with 4x5 Triple Sleeves (3x2=6), so I like having a 6-sheet developing tank.

[Greg]

(While I'd prefer a better option, like a Jobo 3010, that's out of my price range at the moment after buying a camera, lenses, etc. Perhaps I can consider it in a few months.)

Yes the 3010 goes for around $600.00 new. Keep your eye out for a used one. Probably 4-5 years ago I found one up for auction (at a buy it now price) for about 25% of that price. Described as used but when I got it I really think that it was never used. I've seen some JOBO drums that were unlabeled go for bargain prices... bought one that takes two 11x14s from an American seller/dealer. Side by side with an OEM JOBO, I can see absolutely no difference.

[darr]

Yes the 3010 goes for around $600.00 new. Keep your eye out for a used one. Probably 4-5 years ago I found one up for auction (at a buy it now price) for about 25% of that price. Described as used but when I got it I really think that it was never used. I've seen some JOBO drums that were unlabeled go for bargain prices... bought one that takes two 11x14s from an American seller/dealer. Side by side with an OEM JOBO, I can see absolutely no difference.

Last year I bought a 3010 in like-new condition from Camera West. The only problem, I prefer semi-stand processing now.
I never used it and even bought a very good condition used Unicolor Uniroller for it.
One of these days, I will put it up for sale because I found a sweet spot in semi-stand development.

So if you think you may be inclined to try stand or semi-stand development, sadly, the 3010 is not an option.

[Michael R]

B’s is a much better device than the MOD54.

[Ulophot]

I have the 4323 tank from decades ago and the 2 reels that came with it. For larger batches (up to 12 4x5 )I like it very much; I use it with an old Beseler color print drum base. The top is a bit of a chore to screw on fully, maybe just my particular tank.

I also use the Stearman 445. Following Tim's agitation directions to the proverbial letter resolved some uneven development I was getting with slower end-over end routine. It's quick and economical for loads form 1 to 4 sheets. If using 1 or 2, face it/them to the tank's outer walls.

[Alan9940]

Tim just released the SP-645 which does six sheets in one run. That may fit your needs perfectly.

[Joseph Kashi]

I’ve been using the 5x7 BW King 6-sheet stainless reels and tanks out of China. These will work with both 4x5 and 5x7 sheets when loaded using the 5 “ edge. These handle just like big 120 SS reels and tanks and are effective. I bought my two sets new on EBay but they no longer seem to be offered for sale as new units.

[Fungus]

Yes the 3010 goes for around $600.00 new. Keep your eye out for a used one. Probably 4-5 years ago I found one up for auction (at a buy it now price) for about 25% of that price. Described as used but when I got it I really think that it was never used. I've seen some JOBO drums that were unlabeled go for bargain prices... bought one that takes two 11x14s from an American seller/dealer. Side by side with an OEM JOBO, I can see absolutely no difference.

I’ll keep my eyes open for a used 3010. There’s only one used one up on eBay at the moment and the guy wants $500–I’d rather buy new than pay that.