Harrison VS BTZS for 4x5

[Christianganko]

good evening

Was wondering what peoples experiences were with these two?

I mainly shoot outdoors and on the street.

Any perspectives with pros and cons is greatly appreciated.

CHris

[Lachlan 717]

I assume you’re referring to dark cloths?

[Christianganko]

yes

[Peter Lewin]

Any question like this will get a variety of preferences. I've been using a 4x5 for a very long time, and simply use a heavy weight black tee shirt with the neck stretched around the GG and my head inserted in the hem.

[Roger Thoms]

Long time BTZS hood user, what I like is that they are compact and they really block out the light, which helps a lot when focusing my f8 and f9 lenses. I also have a Black Jacket which is pretty nice too but it doesn’t block out quite as much light as the BTZS hood. Haven’t used the Harrison although I did buy one for my 7x17 so I could drop it over leaky bellows, but that project stalled out so I can’t comment on the Harrison other than it’s nicely made.

Roger

[Christianganko]

Thanks so much. I imagine th eharrison you can drape over the whole camera if you really need to? Well, thats what it looks like to me from th eimages on the site.

[Christianganko]

Long time BTZS hood user, what I like is that they are compact and they really block out the light, which helps a lot when focusing my f8 and f9 lenses. I also have a Black Jacket which is pretty nice too but it doesn’t block out quite as much light as the BTZS hood. Haven’t used the Harrison although I did buy one for my 7x17 so I could drop it over leaky bellows, but that project stalled out so I can’t comment on the Harrison other than it’s nicely made.

Roger

Is it at all heavy and is it easy to fold up small?? My back pack is not huge. I also hate having to flaff about when i am working as the one i currently have is pretty light and any gust will have me looking like a crazy person trying to cath hold of it

[Roger Thoms]

Is it at all heavy and is it easy to fold up small?? My back pack is not huge. I also hate having to flaff about when i am working as the one i currently have is pretty light and any gust will have me looking like a crazy person trying to cath hold of it

I definitely prefer the BTZS over a traditional darkcloth if it windy. My 4x5 BTZS hood rolls up into a 3" diameter x 8" long bundle and weights 14 oz / 390 grams. What I tend to do, is to fold it in half or thirds and use it for additional padding for my camera so it doesn't take up much room at all.

Roger

[Christianganko]

I definitely prefer the BTZS over a traditional darkcloth if it windy. My 4x5 BTZS hood rolls up into a 3" diameter x 8" long bundle and weights 14 oz / 390 grams. What I tend to do, is to fold it in half or thirds and use it for additional padding for my camera so it doesn't take up much room at all.

Roger

Thanks Roger

I placed an order today. Will see how it goes but it looks like it would be perfect for me.

Still curious about the Harrison though. But havent seen so many things out there about it.

May opt for one in the near future purely out of curiosity!

[Alan Klein]

Here's a nice video comparing the two types. Maybe I've been using my Harrison wrong as the video shows it around the front of the camera and not around the rear standard as I use. Also, I have asymmetrical adjustments with the rear standard which may make it more difficult to use in the back. I'll have to try the video's method.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vbEsE06g0oM