Trays aren't so bad if you are doing 5x7 and 8x10 stuff, and don't do any special processing -- like toners. But with larger prints, trays are a royal pain in the butt -- wasting space in a cramped location, dealing with spills, working always in the dark. Ridiculous.
With tubes you basically need no space at all -- even with large prints. You get to work with the lights on. You use fresh chemicals each time. I've never had a problem with leaks. I've never had a problem with fiber-based paper -- except that it sticks to the inside of the tube and requires more care in removal from the tube. There's also less fumes -- especially in a cramped space.
It's a personal choice of course. Some photographers like to work in the dark with their hands in the chemicals so they can show their blackened fingernails to their friends. "I love the smell of acetic acid in the morning." More power to 'em.
Bookmarks