Originally Posted by
John Layton
I've stood by my trusty Sironar-N MC (for both 4x5 and 5x7) since I got it new as a "dealer's special" back in the late 1980's (from who...Art Doxer - or maybe even Bob?). At any rate, I've never truly felt the need to move to anything else, even as I've lately been printing very large (up to 40x60). Furthermore, I believe that the design of this lens is slightly more biased towards a bit closer focus distance than is the Sironar-S - which, for my uses, makes it a bit more useful overall. I also figure that atmospheric conditions could render the "S" version's small bit of extra resolution at longer distances moot. Plus, I often shoot at or near diffraction-limited apertures anyway. I also like the fact that the 67mm filter size is compatible with my 90mm and 305mm lenses (Grandagon and G-Claron).
Having said the above...if I did feel compelled to change things up, and if I could swing the $$...I would take a very serious look at the Sironar-S. From everything I've heard and read about this lens - it sounds amazing!
Edit...just noticed that you'd mentioned "all in the same price range." Is the Sironar S in as good condition as the other two? If so, it might be a bargain!
Bookmarks