Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 16

Thread: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

  1. #1

    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    15

    Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    So I've set up a very small/minimal darkroom for 8x10 tank development. This is my first attempt at 8x10 developing and developing at home with no "real" darkroom. (My darkroom is pretty much a sealed cardboard box - which does the job.)

    I went out this weekend, shot six images and developed the negatives. Nothing turned out - I sort of expected this. The negatives had broad unevenly developed streaks, were over-all uneven in development, splotchy, under exposed and unrecognizable. I made the mistake of bringing my cell phone into the darkroom and it went off, so that can account for some of the uneven development, but not everything. My thoughts are that I didn't mix the developer properly and then didn't leave the negatives in long enough. So I was hoping some of you with more experience could help show me where I went wrong. Below is my current process.

    Equipment:
    • 3 8x10 custom made 5L developing tanks
    • 6 8x10 film hangers
    • Assorted Beakers
    • Milliliter Syringe
    • Thermometer
    • 2 3 Gallon Amber Glass Bottles
    • Amber Darkroom Light


    Chemicals & Process:
    • Film: Blue Sensitive X-Ray film
    • Process: In total darkness, remove film from camera holders. Place into 8x10 film hangers.
    • Developer: Adox Rodinal
    • Dilution: 1:200
    • Quantities: 25ml Rodinal : 5L Water
    • Process: Measure and pour Rodinal into 5L container, then pour water at 68 degrees. Mix with custom made spatula. Wait 30 minutes. Use. The mixing is all done before the darkroom is darkened. Once the film is on the hangers, dunk film into 5L tank and wait 6 minutes. No agitation.
    • Stop Bath: Water at 68 degrees.
    • Process: Pour water into 5L tank. Leave it alone. Once the film is in the stop bath for 30 seconds, I flip on the amber light and prepare the Fixer. The film just sits in the stop bath. No agitation. After the fixer is mixed, I move the hangers over to the fixer. (roughly 3-5 minutes in stop bath)
    • Fixer: Photographer's Formulary's TF-4 Archival Fix
    • Dilution: 1:3
    • Quantities: 1L TF-4 : 3L Water
    • Process: Pour TF-4 int 5L tank and mix while film is in the stop bath. Dunk film into fixer and wait 30 seconds. Open darkroom, hello daylight. Final rinse.


    Thank you, any expert advice is appreciated!

  2. #2

    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Greenbank, WA
    Posts
    2,605

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    With the sizeable caveat that I've never worked with x-ray film, a couple observations:

    (1) That seems like a really short development time for Rodinal at so high a dilution. At least for regular film, the time with agitation at one minute intervals would be much, much longer than that.
    (2) Zero agitation generally does not equal even development. Unless there is some reason people don't agitate x-ray flim I don't see why this is being done. The shorter the development time, generally the more important it is to have predictable and even agitation.
    (3) Turning on the lights with unfixed film is generally not a good practice. I did it by mistake myself (with regular film) a month ago, noticed my mistake in about 30 seconds of very bright light, and got the film in the fixer and the negative came out ok. But I was using real stop bath, not water.
    (4) 30 seconds is a very short fix time, especially with no agitation.

    Again, all my experience is with non x-ray film so if I'm way off base I'm sure I'm about to learn that.

  3. #3

    Join Date
    May 2006
    Posts
    82

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    Just an idea, but since you can develop x-ray film under safelight why not do a sheet or two in a tray so you can see what is going on and get an idea of how much time is needed for your process? Scratching is the biggest problem with this method, but if you are careful it can be done. I've done brush on x-ray for agitation but it leaves marks unless the brush is very soft.

    I don't wait 30 minutes before using rodinal. Is this a thing?

    Fix seems way short, but you can know for sure by watching it and when the film clears double that time.

  4. #4

    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    15

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    Hey Kevin,

    Thanks for the reply, your feedback was very helpful. First, I should specify, that sizable caveat you talked about with X-Ray film? There's two of us in it.

    My lack of experience/knowledge is in LF film developing in general, X-Ray film is attractive because it's cheap. So I don't mind if I mess-up while learning along the way.

    From what I've read, there isn't that much difference between it and other film... There are a few differences. It has emulsion on both sides, it's high contrast and very delicate. Hence the high dilution and lack of agitation - at least that's how I understand it. If someone want's to enlighten my, I'm all ears.

    (1) That seems like a really short development time for Rodinal at so high a dilution. At least for regular film, the time with agitation at one minute intervals would be much, much longer than that.
    That's what I thought, but I know I read that development time from somewhere. I'll double check my sources and figure it out.

    (3) Turning on the lights with unfixed film is generally not a good practice. I did it by mistake myself (with regular film) a month ago, noticed my mistake in about 30 seconds of very bright light, and got the film in the fixer and the negative came out ok. But I was using real stop bath, not water.
    Heh, looking back I see that was a mistake. Thanks for pointing it out. Back in the day, I used a dark room for developing 35mm negatives... I think I got confused with the printing process when I switched to 8x10. Those 8x10 sheets sure feel reminiscent to print paper. I guess muscle memory is hard to kill.

    (4) 30 seconds is a very short fix time, especially with no agitation.
    I'll have to double check, but I think the TF-4 said to mix for a 30 second fix. It sounded short to me as well. Another thing I'll double check, I might have to do some trail and error testing, what's a good rule of thumb for fixer?

    Thanks again for the helpful feedback.

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    15

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    Just an idea, but since you can develop x-ray film under safelight why not do a sheet or two in a tray so you can see what is going on and get an idea of how much time is needed for your process? Scratching is the biggest problem with this method, but if you are careful it can be done. I've done brush on x-ray for agitation but it leaves marks unless the brush is very soft.
    That's a great idea, except I'm poor and this is all I got at the moment. So for now, I'm stuck with tanks. EDIT: You can develop X-Ray film under a safelight?

    I don't wait 30 minutes before using rodinal. Is this a thing?
    That could be a problem actually, I wanted a good mix. Now that I think about it, waiting might cause the Rodinal and water to separate. Do you mix your batch and just go straight in?

    Fix seems way short, but you can know for sure by watching it and when the film clears double that time.
    Interesting, I'll have to give this a shot... if I'm using a tank, can I just pull it out and check? Or could that cause streaks?

  6. #6

    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Greenbank, WA
    Posts
    2,605

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    After I put up that post I did some research to see how totally off the mark I would be. Some people do recommend the 1:200 Rodinal, but I see development times for some x-ray films being 1:50 and for 10+ minutes. People do indicate it is very sensitive to over agitation but I don't think that means don't agitate as well. What will happen with very dilute no agitation development is that you will exhaust the developer locally on highlights. If you are doing 3 sheets at once, you should check for the capacity of the rodinal to make sure that 25 ml is enough for all that surface area. As effective film speeds are widely given for these films, we can assume you're at least in the ballpark there.

  7. #7

    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Greenbank, WA
    Posts
    2,605

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    I did see this thread from about six years ago, but that is a different film than the one you are using:

    I have been messing with green sensitive x-ray film. I have attached an early 8x10 image which was developed in D76 1:3 for about six minutes. As perhaps you can see from the scan, I didn't manage to completely tame the contrast with this developer, so following Chris Nze and Jim Galli's advice, I switched to Rodinal. I am currently developing green sensitive Xray film (50 ISO) for Kallitypes in Rodinal 1:200 for about six minutes. This is working very well for me, and at 58¢ a sheet for 11x14 I really can't complain!

  8. #8

    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    15

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    What will happen with very dilute no agitation development is that you will exhaust the developer locally on highlights. If you are doing 3 sheets at once, you should check for the capacity of the rodinal to make sure that 25 ml is enough for all that surface area. As effective film speeds are widely given for these films, we can assume you're at least in the ballpark there.
    I checked the Rodinal website, admittedly, I should have checked this before. The recommended dose of Rodinal per 8x10 sheet is 5ml. So I was close, but off by 5ml since I'm exposing 6 sheets per Rodinal dunk. Does this keep those highlights from getting exhausted, since it's the recommended dose per sheet? Seems like an efficient way to use my developer.

    I have been messing with green sensitive x-ray film. I have attached an early 8x10 image which was developed in D76 1:3 for about six minutes. As perhaps you can see from the scan, I didn't manage to completely tame the contrast with this developer, so following Chris Nze and Jim Galli's advice, I switched to Rodinal. I am currently developing green sensitive Xray film (50 ISO) for Kallitypes in Rodinal 1:200 for about six minutes. This is working very well for me, and at 58¢ a sheet for 11x14 I really can't complain!
    You know, this reads very similar to what I found. Maybe it's what I saw and where I got the 6 minute development time. It is a different film, though I don't think it matters if you have blue or green sensitive film. I could be dead wrong. The massive dev charts for Rodinal unfortunately did not have my film listed, no surprise there, but just looking at the development times for 50 ISO films diluted at 1:200 (or 1:133.33 now), gave me a range of 20-50 minutes. That gives me something to play with. I think we can rule out 6 minutes.

  9. #9

    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Greenbank, WA
    Posts
    2,605

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    I think you'll find you get a bit more density with 4 to 8 X longer development.

  10. #10

    Join Date
    Jun 2014
    Posts
    2,084

    Re: Rodinal with X-Ray Film - Some Problems

    With blue x-ray film (exposed at iso 50), I develop in rodinal 1+100 for about 8-10 minutes, gentle agitation every two minutes. Turning on the light during a diy stop bath severely fogs my film. Fixing is really quick (1-2 minutes) due to the thin emulsion. Blue x-ray film can be handled under a safelight that's used for wet printing, but a red led lamp works very well too and will allow you to use green x-ray film as well.

    So I'd suggest the following:
    Develop longer and/or use a stronger developer.
    Don't turn on the light until fixing is complete.
    Use a safelight to judge progress.
    Fix for a little longer.

Similar Threads

  1. Efke 100 & Rodinal...Problems
    By Mark_Se in forum Darkroom: Film, Processing & Printing
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 16-May-2010, 01:43
  2. Rodinal and sheet film
    By Richard Littlewood in forum Darkroom: Film, Processing & Printing
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-Mar-2009, 23:55
  3. Formulary Rodinal problems!
    By ilikedags in forum Darkroom: Film, Processing & Printing
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 25-May-2008, 04:47
  4. Looking to do some Semi-stand 4x5 with Rodinal... what Film?
    By brian steinberger in forum Darkroom: Film, Processing & Printing
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 18-May-2007, 05:02
  5. efke 100 sheet film in Agfa Rodinal?
    By David Haardt in forum Darkroom: Film, Processing & Printing
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 26-Jul-2001, 11:54

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •