Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 11

Thread: Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

  1. #1

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    Hi all,

    I have been looking at the availiable 4x5 field cameras and I am having trouble deciding which one is for me. I would like a solid camera, with somewhat low wei ght. I currently own a Tachahara and early on I noticed that there was several m illimeters of play in the front standard when everthing is locked. I just don't see the point of carrying a heavy tripod, ball head etc. and a camera which is n ot rigid. I don't need a camera that is built like a tank but I won't put up wit h any looseness in the critical parts of the camera. I shoot landscapes, usually I dayhike to my location but I may try some overnight backpacks. Here is my cur rent analysis:

    Horseman VH: Seems to be a great camera but I noticed that the tilt spec is 10 d egrees forward and 15 degrees backward. Is this sufficient? Say I want to photog raph a flower that is 5 feet in front of me while still having the background i n focus. As a comparison, the Toyo 45AX has tilt of over 90 degrees. I don't wa nt more movements than I will need but I also want a camera which will not restr ict my landscape photography.

    Toyo 45AX: Specs seem good, but fairly heavy. I would like to draw the line at a bout 4 lbs but I could live with 6 if the Horseman movements are not sufficient.

    Gowland Pocket view (or other Gowlands): Excellent weight, but will it have pla y in the standards like my Tach? Maybe I could buy this for backpacking and use the Toyo for dayhikes.

    Others?

    I appreciate all comments. Anyone out there have a Horseman VH or HD?

    Thanks,

    Alex Horvath

  2. #2

    Join Date
    Dec 1997
    Location
    Seattle, Washington
    Posts
    67

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    Hi,

    I recently went through a similar "agony". Have you looked at the Canham DLC? This was the camera I settled on. Solidly built and light enough to pack with ( around 4~5 lbs -- the actual specs escape me). To me, this seemed like a better camera than the Toyo (with a capability of really wide angle to telephoto witho ut changing bellows).

    Robert

  3. #3

    Join Date
    Mar 1998
    Posts
    1,973

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    B&H says that a Horseman VH (a 6x9cm camera) is priced at US$2069; a Horseman HD is priced at US$1980.00. I second Robert R. recommendation of the Canham DLC ($ 2150); a fresnel might (depends on dealer) cost you an additional $150. I have t he Technika to DLC lens board adapter, that cost another $150.00 but isn't neces sary. My total outlay was $2300. I have a very solid and versatile, yet light, f ield camera with a very simple mechanism that is easy to clean in the field.

  4. #4

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    I vote for the DLC also. With this camera it is not necessary to carry a heavy t ripod and ball head. It locks as you wished for and is pretty no nonsense. I am currently hiking a lot with it and am using it on the small Gitzo Carbon, as lo ng as I hang my camera bag to it it is a very steady and locked down platform. I t is also a very cool looking insturment.

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Mar 1998
    Location
    Anchorage, AK
    Posts
    288

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    I have a Linhof Technikardan 4x5, which I like very much. However, I purchased it as a used camera for about what you would pay for a new Canham 4x5! One other advantage of the Canham is that you supposedly don't need to purchase bag bello ws ($$$!) for wide angle lenses. You can read a review of the Canham at the Vie w Camera web site (www.viewcamera.com)

    All of that aside, I think that you should ask yourself what kind of landscape p hotography you tend to do. Do you concentrate on wide angle images, or are you more into long focal length images? Or do you do a bit of everything? If you p refer long focal lengths, you may not find the Canham adequate. Alternatively, if you work mostly with wide angle lenses, another less expensive camera may be what available. I don't have suggestions for these end members. But I do think that purchasing a one-does-it-all camera, like the TK45 or the Canham, isn't ne cessarily the best choice for everyone.

    Finally, I would try to borrow or rent one of whatever you consider purchasing. I've never had a problem operating my TK45, but as you can see by one of the ar ticles on this site's main page, not everyone would agree. I suspect that the s imilar issues apply to the Canham or any other camera.

    Best wishes, Bruce

  6. #6

    Join Date
    Aug 1998
    Posts
    32

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    Just to add to your agony, if you buy a toyo ax or aii (YES EITHER of them) you will get a new l 778 spot meter for 100 bux. If you dont already have a nice spo t meter this is the deal to grab (700US for the meter alone). There is a special on toyos too, so you can get it for 1500 and 19xx repectively.

    Or you can buy an elph jr and enjoy life. (JK)

    al

  7. #7
    lazy retired bum
    Join Date
    Sep 1998
    Location
    Lake Oswego, Oregon
    Posts
    264

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    I LOVE my Toyo Field. It has the advantage of being rock solid and is made by a company that's been there and will likely be there for a while. The meter deal i s also good if you are in the market for a meter. If I had it to do all over aga in, now (I've had my Toyo for over 10 years), I'd certainly strongly consider th e Canham. It sounds terrific but I've been unable to actually touch one. Since a camera like this is a virtual lifetime purchase for most amaturs, be careful an d deliberate. I've played with a used Technikardan and was not impressed. It did not seem intuitive to me. 4X5 work is slow work, by its very nature, take your time in this purchase.

  8. #8

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    I just went through this same agony over my new field camera (I shoot landscape and marine senics and I travel a great deal with my camera). After trying both a Toyo and a Linhof for a few days (and considering the Horseman), I bought a Wis ta SP. Now, two months later, I am certain that I made the right choice. The Wis ta is as well built, if not better, than the Linhof. It's far superior to the To yo in every way (more movements, geared movments, smoother, more rigid, easier t o use, and it has a real precise feel that the Toyo lacks,) but it cost about th e same as a Toyo. That is to say, it cost 1/2 as much as a Linhof. In addition i t has changable bellows and focusing tracks which no other metal field camera ha s. I knew nothing about Wistas when I started looking for a new camera; they see m to be a rather small Japanese company that had almost no US distribution. But now that B&H carries them, I'll bet Toyo and Linhof will be selling a fewer came ras.

    Chris

  9. #9

    Join Date
    Mar 1998
    Posts
    1,973

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    Chris , I am glad you are happy with your Wista, but your statement "...it has changable bellows and focusing tracks which no other metal field camera has." while it ma ybe technically correct, less appealing then the Canham DLC which doesn't need e xtra focusing tracks (unless you are using a lens longer than a 720mm telephoto) or interchangable bellows for full movements with lenses as short as 55mm (if t he 55mm APO-Grandagon ismounted on a recessed board, no recessed board is needed if you are using the 58mm Schneider Super Angulon XL).

  10. #10

    Join Date
    Jun 1998
    Posts
    53

    Agonizing over which 4x5 field camera to purchase

    I can understand your feelings that the Wista SP feels more "precise" than a Toy o. The geared movements should probably translate to that precise feeling. I hav en't had my hands on a Wista but the brochure imparts the feeling you describe.

    The Toyo AX, however, is priced quite a bit below the AII and the SP (assuming n ew, of course). As you might recall, the introduction of the AII was accompanied with a $700 price increase over its predecessor, the A. Improvements were prett y insignificant if you relate them to the $700 increase.

    You may find this interesting. I sent an email to Mamiya about 2 years ago (befo re the AX) and asked if they made an AII without the revolving back. I figured i t would be lighter and less expensive. There response was, "No", but the RB only weighted about 6/10 of a pound. So, the AX was of interest to me upon its intro duction and I own one now.

    But that's off the point. And the point is, I suspect the AX is doing nicely in sales because of quality/price. And, I don't think Linhof has to be concerned ab out the Wista as competition. That's not to say the Wista isn't a great camera b ut that Linhof appeals to a different buyer.

    The other thing is, it would be really hard not to like ANY of the cameras you w ere considering. They are all fine instruments.

    Also, congratulations!

    Mike

Similar Threads

  1. How do I get my 8X10 field camera and gear out into the field
    By steve Barth in forum Location & Travel
    Replies: 33
    Last Post: 30-Dec-2006, 09:16
  2. Agonizing on Apertures -- photos done wide open
    By Frank Petronio in forum Lenses & Lens Accessories
    Replies: 26
    Last Post: 29-Apr-2006, 18:44
  3. Purchase of camera
    By Tom Arnhold in forum Cameras & Camera Accessories
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 30-Sep-2005, 10:48
  4. Kodak 2D 8x10 field camera and assorted lenses-should I purchase?
    By Jeffrey Fookson in forum Cameras & Camera Accessories
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 8-Sep-2000, 21:23
  5. Wood field camera vs metal technical camera
    By Ron_673 in forum Cameras & Camera Accessories
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 28-Jul-1999, 23:26

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •