Just to set the record straight, I use baby oil only with very long scans where the low viscosity often results in separation of the negative from the glass. For other work I use Kami fluid since clean-up is less of a problem. Separation of the negative from the glass with long scans is a problem in my work because I don't use a sheet of mylar over the negative. The mylar, IMO, causes more problems than it is worth.
Johnson Baby Oil was recommended to me by someone with years and years of experiene with drum scanning, with the full assurance that it was entirely safe for this purpose. I am not aware of tests that show that any of the other fluids used for mouting negatives are any safer than baby oil, and unless someone can point me to such tests I will assume their concern that baby oil is not safe amounts to no more than speculation. I will certainly re-consider my use of baby oil if any evidence is available that it is less safe than fluids such as Kami and Prazio because I value my negatives just as much as anyone on this forum.
As for negative clean-up, I discussed the possible negative effects of degreasers with a former film engineer from Kodak. His primary concern was that many household degreasers work at a fairly high pH, which in theory could allow swelling of the gelatin in the film emulsion. For that reason I tested the pH of several different degreasers and selected one that works at neutral pH.
Sandy King
Bookmarks