I was the one who started that other thread. I wasn't conclusive on its look. Not enough people have used this film yet. I ended up getting 3 rolls of it in 120 (since 120 was all I could get at the time). I haven't sent it off to be developed yet though. Im waiting to send my batches of film off. I was told it was mid contrast in its look, and similar to Panatomic X. But I question if this new film is as good as Pan X. Certainly Pan X has better quality control.