PDA

View Full Version : Portrait Lens Andrew Ross (London) 1850s



heritagefutures
25-Feb-2012, 21:11
Hi,

I have in hand a Petzval -Design Portrait Lens marked A Ross London with sn 4703

http://www.flickr.com/photos/heritagefutures/6781703948/

I am trying to get more detail on the nature of the lens and in particular on similar early Ross lenses that may be out there.
To be upfront: I am trying to gauge the rarity of the lens so that I don't make a fool of myself when I offer it for swap/trade (as it will be highly unlikely that I will use it)...
Any suggestions (here or comment on the Flickr photo) would be much welcomed.

Cheers from OZ
Dirk
www.ausphoto.net (http://www.ausphoto.net)

heritagefutures
25-Feb-2012, 21:50
More photos of the lens ca be found here:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/heritagefutures/sets/72157629449309381/

Steven Tribe
26-Feb-2012, 01:58
No one can/will put a price on this. The market is small and most into using this kind of lens in LF have already gotten themselves a 50's Petzval. As you say "it will be highly unlikely that I will use it" - this applies to others, unless they are into still life or portraits and Sinar Copal shutters with very solid cameras.

heritagefutures
26-Feb-2012, 02:01
No one can/will put a price on this. The market is small ....
Thanks Steven, that's what I feared from the price side. Still, surely 1850s Ross lenses aren't that common..no collectors out there?

Steven Tribe
26-Feb-2012, 02:11
There are surely some, especialy as this is A.Ross period with the Rofs engraving of which perhaps just a few hundred have survived.
But optically, I think that there is not too much difference between the various early Petzval makers in the 50's - see CCHarrison's website summary of makers in the different periods.

heritagefutures
26-Feb-2012, 02:17
yep, I can see your point on the optical side of things...
still, would love to see how many early A Ross are out there, aport from what's listed here (http://www.earlyphotography.co.uk/site/SRL_lenses.html#Ross)
will see what others might know...I am in no hurry and rather do my research properly...

Emil Schildt
26-Feb-2012, 04:20
At least two in here have one like that - slightly older...

Mine:

http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/attachment.php?attachmentid=61461&d=1316614968

Post 29: richard K has a really old one!

http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/showthread.php?58528-Your-Oldest-Lens/page3&highlight=ross

this thread:

http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/showthread.php?58528-Your-Oldest-Lens

heritagefutures
26-Feb-2012, 04:33
At least two in here have one like that - slightly older...
Excellent! What size is yours? same, 12 Inch?
That lens of Richard's is an amazingly low serial! (http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/showthread.php?58528-Your-Oldest-Lens&p=644427&viewfull=1#post644427)

eddie
26-Feb-2012, 04:42
the trouble is that in today's market the real rare and collectible lenses often do not get any "extra" or higher price as people just are not aware that they are rare or unusual. many time those lens actually get less than a similar more well know piece. i suspect that will be the case on your lens. even when they are engraved "ross" most of the lenses so not command a high(er) price. so one engraved "rolf" is likely to be missed all together. i do not believe this lens to be that rare.....i have seen and handled several.

another issue is there are not many true collectors in the market. most are users. so again a "rare" lens is lost to most.

goamules
26-Feb-2012, 07:25
I agree with the above. The market for LF lenses for all types is fairly small. A small subset like the old brass ones. An even smaller subset look for the uncommon or early ones. Personally, I like the older lenses, and think one day they will rise above the others. But it all depends on the whims of the collectors/users. Look at the classic car boom and bust the past 10 years. American muscle cars like corvettes and GTOs were going up in price every sale. While earlier Model A and T Fords just kept their value or went up slightly. At one point you couldn't get a 1960s big block Corvette for under $25,000, yet a Model A was still $8,000 or so. Of course, they made a lot of the Fords, so it's not a good example. But I collect several early maker brass lenses, some only made for less than 10 years, but typically their prices are below Dallmeyers, where were made from 1863 (if I recall) to the 1930s. For every Jamin Cone Centralisateur made there were probably 1,000 Dallmeyer A and B model petzvals, yet the latter are what people want right now.

Two23
26-Feb-2012, 11:50
I'm not an expert, but would call myself a "newbie collector." I own four Petzvals at the moment, dating from from 1850s to early 1870s, including Grubb, Voigtlander, Derogy, Darlot. I've been zeroing in on lenses made before 1860 and am especially after a lens from the 1840s. I also own a pillbox lens made in 1855. I have some thoughts. Your lens is a good length, a good brand, and the glass is in good shape. On the negative, it has no flange and the brass is a little rough looking. Another thing is that lenses made before 1860 or so did not have slots. Yours does, making me wonder if the slot was added later or maybe the lens was actually made after ~1860 (less likely since many added the slot.) I'll take a rough stab at a price, something the wiser Steven Tribe passed on here. :D I'm going to say the lens would probably sell in the $400 to $650 range on eBay. If I had to guess a specific price, I'd say $500. Again, that's a guess and it depends on how badly two people want a Ross lens. Note that last month I bought an even rarer lens, a Grubb Petzval made in the 1850s for $360 (no flange). The CC Harrisons and Voigtlanders seem to go for much more, all things equal. As Steven said above, most people who really want an 1850s Petzval already have one. That's the case for me, too. I have two, I think, and may sell one this year. Now if you can come up with a lens from the 1840s, I'm interested.


Kent in SD

Steven Tribe
26-Feb-2012, 12:27
Here is an illustration of the uncertain situation (supply and demand, hence price) with a very recently sold lens on E**y 251000984372.
The maker is Horne & Thornthwaite , another recognised maker of Petzvals. This is different, a Landscape lens with a quite unique lateral and internal stop selection slider, which I think was put there by H & T69028. Made a few years after 1857. Lens VM does just mention the type, but not the "patent" iris system. 2 bidders and winning bid was £90. Very cheap for a piece of optical history. This is about the usual price these days for very "ordinary" large landscape lenses of the end of the century!

Sorry about the odd appearance - the new system cheated me! You have to "attack" the blue text to get the image.