PDA

View Full Version : Should we have a LFP Hall of Fame?


Milonian
3-Jun-2016, 09:33
Just recently I've had great advice and communication from a couple of members and I wondered if we should have a Hall of Fame where users can nominate people who have gone the extra mile.
Tin Can
3-Jun-2016, 10:09
No!
Willie
3-Jun-2016, 11:32
Jorge Gasteazoro. Steve Simmons. Frank Patronio.
Those would be a good start.
mdarnton
3-Jun-2016, 12:39
No.
Kevin Crisp
3-Jun-2016, 13:03
No.
Jac@stafford.net
3-Jun-2016, 13:14
No!
David Lobato
3-Jun-2016, 13:18
Too difficult to avoid it being subjective, no. Plus, there are so many people here who are such great help as it is. Too many good contributors who can't all be recognized.
Jim Jones
3-Jun-2016, 15:03
No. Lets concentrate on the best photography, not the best people.
Peter De Smidt
3-Jun-2016, 15:19
No.
jnantz
3-Jun-2016, 15:45
there already is one

http://www.largeformatphotography.info/credits.html
http://www.largeformatphotography.info/forum/faq.php?faq=vb_faq

and not to mention the moderators ...
Wayne
3-Jun-2016, 15:59
Jorge Gasteazoro. Steve Simmons. Frank Patronio.
Those would be a good start.

Rofl. :) I don't think it would lead to productive discussion, but people alre always welcome to mention their faves.
goamules
3-Jun-2016, 16:01
No!
Taija71A
3-Jun-2016, 16:20
Jorge Gasteazoro. Steve Simmons. Frank Patronio...

Since, Jorge and Steve haven't been on the Forum since 2009...
And Frank is now found elsewhere...


... I don't think it would lead to productive discussion...

Agreed...

Whether it be a Large Format Photography 'Hall of Fame' or 'Hall of Shame' (*Just joking of course everybody)... :) :p ;) :D
Both, could be 'tantamount' to skiing... On a very, perilous Slope.
Ari
3-Jun-2016, 20:21
Just recently I've had great advice and communication from a couple of members and I wondered if we should have a Hall of Fame where users can nominate people who have gone the extra mile.

Doubt it would fly, but a nice thought.
But maybe we can bow our heads slightly in the direction of all those who keep the "Nude" thread going? :)
Jim Noel
4-Jun-2016, 07:59
No!

Here is another "NO"
Dan Fromm
4-Jun-2016, 08:07
Just recently I've had great advice and communication from a couple of members and I wondered if we should have a Hall of Fame where users can nominate people who have gone the extra mile.

No.

If you want to thank helpful people, either thank them privately via private message, publicly by expressing gratitude in a reply to a post you found helpful, or in a new post thanking named individuals for assistance (and spell out what they did for you).
David Karp
4-Jun-2016, 10:37
Nope.
Bruce Watson
4-Jun-2016, 12:04
No. Keep the focus on photography.
koh303
4-Jun-2016, 14:31
No. Keep the focus on photography.

But how?
Bruce Watson
4-Jun-2016, 14:35
But how?

Um... by not having an LFP Hall of Fame?
scheinfluger_77
4-Jun-2016, 14:40
But how?

Shoooot mor pichers... (He said pointedly with three fingers pointing back at himself)
koh303
4-Jun-2016, 15:42
Um... by not having an LFP Hall of Fame?

There is almost no discussion about photography in this forum, unless you count photonerds techno babble as photography.
Why not then have a hall of fame and shame?
Tin Can
4-Jun-2016, 15:49
Do we self nominate?


There is almost no discussion about photography in this forum, unless you count photonerds techno babble as photography.
Why not then have a hall of fame and shame?
Oren Grad
4-Jun-2016, 15:59
Milonian, it's kind of you to want to show appreciation. But I'm afraid that for the Hall of Fame idea, the answer is no, for reasons already stated.