Gitzo 1325 or 1548 for TK45?

[Jon_2416]

Hey all,

I can get a good deal on either a used Gitzo 1325 or 1548 carbon fiber tripod. I don't backpack and either will be strapped to my Lowepro roller case. I generally shoot in the city and don't find myself in windy conditions. I've been using a Bogen 3041 which isn't rigid enough and also have a Bogen 3036 which is an animal... even for my Technikardan. I'm going to get an Acratech ballhead to replace the small Bogen I've been using.

Any users out there? Any votes either way?

[George Stewart]

The Acratech will look very strange on the 1548 (I own both). The top plate on the 1548 is huge. The base of the Acratech is actually smaller than the top plate of the 1229. I'd forget the good deal and get what is right for your needs.

[Mark Windom]

The 1325 should be fine. I used it with a Wista SP...rock solid.

[Kevin Crisp]

The Acratech with the 1325 is a very nice combination, you would be happy with it. I haven't personally used the other tripod model number so can't comment.

[Kerry L. Thalmann]

Jon,

The 1325 should be fine. I used one for years with my TK45S (and now with an ARCA-SWISS F-Line Classic). I use my 1325 with an ARCA-SWISS B1. They make a great combo. Light enough to go anywhere, but rock solid sturdy. I haven't used the Acratech head, but have heard good things about it from those that have. You may want to invest in one of the long quick release plates from Kirk, RRS or Wimberley. They will help center the camera better when using long lenses.

George,

I'm not familiar with the Gitzo 1229. Is this a new model, or perhaps a typo. I've had the 1227 for years and modified it by removing the center column. It's my ultralight tripod for backpacking with my Toho FC-45X. It would be nice if there was a 1200 series Gitzo carbon fiber tripod that came stock with a flat plate and no center column.

Kerry

[Frank Petronio]

Hey Witsell, if you can afford it, go big - get the taller 1549 for urban work. Plus it makes a great back-up weapon when the strap breaks on your Leica. And I like the Arca ballheads too, on my smaller tripod, and I use a geared three-way on my big tripod now. Geared heads are great for view cameras...

[Jorge Gasteazoro]

I am going to be the one going against all advice and recommend you get the 1548. I have one with the low profile 1570 head and it is a winning combination, but a ball head should also work fine. Whenever I use my TK (which is rare now) putting it on the tripod is very simple and I have no need of a QR. Additionally I can also place my 8x10 and 12x20 on the same tripod. IOW, if you get the 1548 (specially since you dont plan to hike much) you will have the one tripod that does it all. It will be all you will ever need.

If you were hiking I would say go for the 1325, but seeing that you plan to use the roll case, IMO the 1548 is a no brainer, specially if you can have it at a good price.

[Kerry L. Thalmann]

Geared heads are great for view cameras...

I have to agree with Frank on this one. Even though I generally favor lightweight gear, I've become a bit spoiled by the geared head I've been using for everything but really long hikes and backpacking lately. I terms of strength/weight ratio, it's hard to beat a top quality ballhead (ARCA B1, Acratech, etc.), but boy, for ease of use a three axis geared head is pure joy to use. Since Jon mentioned that weight wasn't an issue, I'm wondering why he's considering the Acratech. One of it's main selling points is the light weight (less than 1 lb.). Where weight isn't an issue, I think any three axis head (geared, or not) would be easier to use with a heavy (8 lb.) large format camera than a ballhead. I continue to use ballheads when weight is an issue, but when it's not, I go for the geared head every time.

Whenever I use my TK (which is rare now) putting it on the tripod is very simple and I have no need of a QR.

Jorge,

I merely mentioned the Kirk, RRS and Wimberley QR plates since Jon stated he was getting the Acratech ballhead, which comes with an ARCA style QR clamp. If he gets another head, he may or may not need a QR plate.

Kerry

[Frank Petronio]

My "architectural" tripod is the largest, tallest 500 metal Gitzo (with the "made in France" stickers removed of course) and a Majestic geared head with a RRS female topper. I can climb on the thing, and the mass makes it impervious to any less than Hurricane Ivan. It cost less than $500 complete, mostly from eBay (the RRS plate was $100). I use a 300 series with a A-S B1 for walking around...

For the cost of a big CF you could get both...

[Don Miller]

The 1325 should be rigid enough if it's tall enough. Few people would purchase a 1500 series for strictly 4x5. It's "an animal". All of the 3,4, and 5 series Gitzos are rigid, expensive tripods suitable for at least 5x7. So pick the price/features that work for you. I have the 1345 (taller four section version of the 1325) and the aluminum 1410. The 1325 would be too short for me.

Re: Geared head comments - I have the acrateach for 35mm/MF. I do not like ball heads -at all- for LF, especially in the geometry of a city. The cheapie geared head that I and many other people use is the Bogen 3275/ Manfrotto 410 (same item). It's under $200 and allows for fine movements in one plane. It weighs about 2x the acratech.

But I do recognize that ball heads work for Jon and others. Perhaps these guys are more coordinated than me.

Don