Repair Artixscan 4500t or buy new Epson 4990?

[Mike Lewis]

I have a Microtek ArtixScan 4500t dedicated film scanner that I bought in fall 2003 for a reduced price, apparently surplus. The 4500t scans up to 4x5 at about 2500 dpi with an advertised Dmax of 3.9. I think the 4500t was first marketed in 2001 at a price of several thousand dollars, and I think Polaroid sold the same scanner as a Sprintscan 45. I used the 4500t to scan 4x5 transparencies in order to print up to 16x20.

About a year after I bought the scanner it quit working. I've contacted Microtek about having the scanner repaired but really haven't pursued it yet, so I don't know how much the repair will cost. Nevertheless, given the advance in scanner technology since 2001, should I forego repairing the 4500t and instead purchase a new Epson 4990 flatbed? I understand that the 4990 is not in the same class as a dedicated film scanner, but I was wondering if the advance in scanner technology since 2001 compensates for that. Please spout your opinions :-).

Thanks.

[Will Strain]

I'd follow up on the repairs, and go with whichever is cheaper. Both will do a fine job, especially if you don't really go over 16x20.

I think the artix is probably a better scanner... but I don't think it is a significant difference (ie. worth huge extra bucks).

[steve simmons]

Before buying a scanner for sheet film read the article in the current issue of View Camera.

steve simmons

[mark blackman]

The View Camera article doesn't cover the Epson 4990. It was interesting reading, showing up manufacturer's claims on Dmax and dpi to be exaggerated. I still think a (relatively) cheap flat bed is a useful tool for the amateur; we can always pay (£30 a sheet in London) for a drum scan as required.

By the way, Steve, I think you'll find that Photoshop's memory limit is 2GB, not 2MB!

[Julian Boulter]

Hi Mark,

Out of interest where do you get you drum scans done for £30? I am thinking of getting some of my 4x5 trannies drum scanned. I have used a few places but most in London seem to charge between £40 and £50 a scan. What is the quality of the scan like for £30?

Thanks

Julian